Back to Casita Palmera
Las Canteras Beach
Local Guide

Canary Islands Comparison 2026 - Which Island Should You Choose?

The definitive guide to choosing your perfect Canary Island

Las Canteras, Gran Canaria 5 min read

The 8 Canary Islands: Overview

The Canary Islands are an archipelago of 8 inhabited islands in the Atlantic Ocean, off the coast of Africa. They belong to Spain and therefore the European Union, but have a special tax regime: instead of standard VAT, they apply IGIC at 7%, making everything slightly cheaper than mainland Spain.

All islands share an eternal spring climate, with average temperatures of 18-24°C year-round and over 300 days of sunshine. Yet each island has a radically different personality. From cosmopolitan cities to islands with no paved roads, there is a Canary Island for every type of traveller.

Key facts for the entire archipelago:

Gran Canaria

"The Miniature Continent." Gran Canaria is the most well-rounded island in the archipelago. Covering 1,560 km² with 850,000 inhabitants, it offers absolutely everything: golden sand beaches, desert dunes, laurel forests, volcanic peaks, a vibrant capital, and charming villages.

Why it stands out

Practical info

Gran Canaria is the only island where you can have breakfast by the sea, go surfing, lunch in a mountain village, visit a museum, and dine at a fine restaurant, all in the same day.

Tenerife

The largest island in the Canaries at 2,034 km² with 928,000 inhabitants. Tenerife is an island of extreme contrasts: from the touristy beaches of the south to the ancient forests of the north, all dominated by Mount Teide, Spain's highest peak.

Why it stands out

Practical info

Tenerife has more tourist infrastructure than any other island, but also more overcrowding in the southern resort zones. The north is green and authentic; the south is dry and purpose-built for tourism.

Lanzarote

The island of art and volcanoes. At 845 km² with 155,000 inhabitants, Lanzarote is a lunar landscape declared a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve. The legacy of artist Cesar Manrique is everywhere, blending art and nature in a way found nowhere else.

Why it stands out

Practical info

Lanzarote is the most "designed" island in the Canaries. If aesthetics, photography, and culture matter to you, this is your island.

Fuerteventura

The island of endless beaches. At 1,659 km² it is the second-largest island, yet has only 120,000 inhabitants. Fuerteventura boasts over 150 km of coastline with some of the longest, most pristine beaches in Europe.

Why it stands out

Practical info

Fuerteventura is the most "empty" of the main islands. If you want beaches without crowds and room to breathe, you will find it here.

La Palma

"La Isla Bonita" (The Beautiful Island), and it earns the name. At 708 km² with 83,000 inhabitants, La Palma is the greenest and most mountainous island in the archipelago. Known for its pristine skies and untouched nature, it experienced a volcanic eruption in 2021 that added dramatic new landscapes.

Why it stands out

Practical info

La Palma is not a beach holiday island. It is for those who want to walk incredible trails, sleep under star-filled skies, and genuinely disconnect.

La Gomera

The wildest of the main islands. At just 370 km² with 22,000 inhabitants, La Gomera is a hiker's paradise free from mass tourism. This is the island where Columbus made his final stop before crossing the Atlantic.

Why it stands out

Practical info

La Gomera is the anti-tourist island. No fast food chains, no nightclubs, no all-inclusive resorts. Just nature, small villages, and silence.

El Hierro

The island at the edge of the world. At 268 km² with just 11,000 inhabitants, El Hierro is the smallest and most remote island in the archipelago. It is the world's first island to be 100% self-sufficient on renewable energy (wind + hydro).

Why it stands out

Practical info

El Hierro is for those who want to drop off the map for a few days. No organised tourism, no rush, no noise.

La Graciosa

The eighth island. At just 29 km² with 750 inhabitants, La Graciosa is the smallest island and was officially recognised as the eighth inhabited island in 2018. It has no paved roads - only sandy tracks.

Why it stands out

Practical info

La Graciosa is a perfect day trip from Lanzarote. There are no hotels above two stars and no white-tablecloth restaurants. Just sand, sea, and silence.

Comparison Table

| | Gran Canaria | Tenerife | Lanzarote | Fuerteventura | La Palma | La Gomera | El Hierro | La Graciosa |

|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|

| Population | 850,000 | 928,000 | 155,000 | 120,000 | 83,000 | 22,000 | 11,000 | 750 |

| Area | 1,560 km² | 2,034 km² | 845 km² | 1,659 km² | 708 km² | 370 km² | 268 km² | 29 km² |

| Airport | LPA | TFS / TFN | ACE | FUE | SPC | GMZ (inter-island) | VDE (inter-island) | None |

| Best beach | Las Canteras | Las Teresitas | Papagayo | Cofete | Nogales | Valle Gran Rey | Tacoron | Las Conchas |

| Top attraction | Roque Nublo + Dunes | Teide (3,718 m) | Timanfaya | Endless beaches | Observatory | Garajonay | Diving | Pristine beaches |

| Best for | Everyone | Nature, families | Art, couples | Beach, surfing | Hiking, stargazing | Hiking, eco | Diving, off-grid | Day trips |

| Accommodation cost | €70-150/night | €70-200/night | €60-150/night | €50-130/night | €50-100/night | €45-90/night | €40-80/night | €50-90/night |

| Crowd level | Medium-high | High | Medium | Medium-low | Low | Very low | Minimal | Minimal |

Our Recommendation

After comparing all 8 islands, our conclusion is straightforward: Gran Canaria is the best island for most travellers. It is not the cheapest or the quietest, but it is the only one that truly has everything.

Why? Because in Gran Canaria you can:

And if you want the best possible base, Las Canteras is the place. A 3.2 km beach in the heart of the capital, with everything on foot and direct connections to the whole island.

From Casita Palmera, our apartment just 30 metres from Las Canteras, you will have the ideal base to explore not just Gran Canaria, but the entire archipelago. Inter-island flights start from €25 and take between 25 and 50 minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Canary Island is cheapest?

El Hierro and La Gomera have the most affordable accommodation (from €40-45/night), but options are limited. Among the major islands, Fuerteventura offers the best value with apartments from €50/night.

Which Canary Island has the best weather?

All have excellent weather, but Fuerteventura and the south of Gran Canaria/Tenerife get the most sunshine hours and the least chance of rain. La Palma and La Gomera are slightly cooler and more humid due to their lush vegetation.

Can you island-hop in the Canaries?

Yes. There are inter-island flights with Binter and Canaryfly (from €25, 25-50 minutes) and ferries with Fred. Olsen and Naviera Armas (from €20). The most frequent connections are Gran Canaria-Tenerife, Tenerife-La Gomera, and Lanzarote-Fuerteventura.

Which Canary Island is best for families?

Gran Canaria and Tenerife are the top choices for families. Both have safe beaches, theme parks, excellent healthcare infrastructure, and a wide range of accommodation. Gran Canaria stands out for Las Canteras, whose sheltered lagoon is ideal for children.

Which Canary Island is the quietest?

El Hierro, without question. With just 11,000 inhabitants and virtually no organised tourism, it is the most remote and peaceful island in the archipelago. La Graciosa is even smaller, but receives a steady flow of day trippers from Lanzarote.

Looking for Accommodation?

Casita Palmera is 50 meters from the beach.

View Apartment